A batch code is a clue about a production run. It is not a certificate of authenticity.
That distinction follows the job batch coding is meant to do: it makes a production lot traceable. For example, the FDA describes adequate lot coding as a way to identify products involved in a recall — not as an authenticity programme. Read the FDA guidance →
A successful result means that the characters you entered fit a batch-code format that we can decode for the selected brand. It can give useful manufacture-date context. It does not inspect the product, verify the seller, or trace the item's journey from a manufacturer to you.
A string can be copied, read from the wrong part of a package, or look plausible without telling the whole story. Treating a decoded date as a definitive authenticity verdict gives the result more authority than it has.
Lotly is intentionally a batch-code checker, not an authenticity verifier. The most honest answer is sometimes simply: this code is decodable, and that is all it proves.